| Abstract|| |
Goal-directed therapy (GDT) encompasses guidance of intravenous (IV) fluid and vasopressor/inotropic therapy by cardiac output or similar parameters to help in early recognition and management of high-risk cardiac surgical patients. With the aim of establishing the utility of perioperative GDT using robust clinical and biochemical outcomes, we conducted the present study. This multicenter randomized controlled study included 130 patients of either sex, with European system for cardiac operative risk evaluation ≥3 undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting on cardiopulmonary bypass. The patients were randomly divided into the control and GDT group. All the participants received standardized care; arterial pressure monitored through radial artery, central venous pressure (CVP) through a triple lumen in the right internal jugular vein, electrocardiogram, oxygen saturation, temperature, urine output per hour, and frequent arterial blood gas (ABG) analysis. In addition, cardiac index (CI) monitoring using FloTrac™ and continuous central venous oxygen saturation (ScVO2) using PreSep™ were used in patients in the GDT group. Our aim was to maintain the CI at 2.5–4.2 L/min/m2, stroke volume index 30–65 ml/beat/m2, systemic vascular resistance index 1500–2500 dynes/s/cm5/m2, oxygen delivery index 450–600 ml/min/m2, continuous ScVO2 >70%, and stroke volume variation <10%; in addition to the control group parameters such as CVP 6–8 mmHg, mean arterial pressure 90–105 mmHg, normal ABG values, oxygen saturation, hematocrit value >30%, and urine output >1 ml/kg/h. The aims were achieved by altering the administration of IV fluids and doses of inotropes or vasodilators. The data of sixty patients in each group were analyzed in view of ten exclusions. The average duration of ventilation (19.89 ± 3.96 vs. 18.05 ± 4.53 h, P = 0.025), hospital stay (7.94 ± 1.64 vs. 7.17 ± 1.93 days, P = 0.025), and Intensive Care Unit (ICU) stay (3.74 ± 0.59 vs. 3.41 ± 0.75 days, P = 0.012) was significantly less in the GDT group, compared to the control group. The extra volume added and the number of inotropic dose adjustments were significantly more in the GDT group. The two groups did not differ in duration of inotropic use, mortality, and other complications. The perioperative continuation of GDT affected the early decline in the lactate levels after 6 h in ICU, whereas the control group demonstrated a settling lactate only after 12 h. Similarly, the GDT group had significantly lower levels of brain natriuretic peptide, neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin levels as compared to the control. The study clearly depicts the advantage of GDT for a favorable postoperative outcome in high-risk cardiac surgical patients.
Keywords: Biomarker; Cardiac surgery; Goal-directed therapy; Outcome measures; Perioperative
|How to cite this article:|
Kapoor PM, Magoon R, Rawat R, Mehta Y. Perioperative utility of goal-directed therapy in high-risk cardiac patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting: “A clinical outcome and biomarker-based study”. Ann Card Anaesth 2016;19:638-82
|How to cite this URL:|
Kapoor PM, Magoon R, Rawat R, Mehta Y. Perioperative utility of goal-directed therapy in high-risk cardiac patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting: “A clinical outcome and biomarker-based study”. Ann Card Anaesth [serial online] 2016 [cited 2020 Jul 2];19:638-82. Available from: http://www.annals.in/text.asp?2016/19/4/638/191552
| Introduction|| |
After undergoing cardiac surgery, most patients have a short Intensive Care Unit (ICU) and hospital stay. However, up to 10% of patients have a complicated postoperative course because of organ dysfunction or multiple organ failure resulting in increased burden on the hospital resources and costs. Limited cardiovascular reserve and an inadequate hemodynamic response to postoperative surgical stress have been shown to be independent predictors of a prolonged ICU stay.,
Cardiac surgery, at present, is being conducted in an increasingly high-risk population as it is backed by continually improving surgical strategy and technology. Shoemaker et al. showed that high-risk cardiac surgical patients had increased morbidity and mortality and the survivors had consistently higher postoperative cardiac output and oxygen delivery than those who died. An understanding emerged that the high mortality rate might be reduced, if the flow-related cardiovascular values become additional goals for perioperative management. An indicator of low cardiac output, global tissue hypoxia is a key development proceeding to multiorgan failure and death. It is in the immediate postcardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) period when the recognition and treatment produce maximal benefit in outcome.
Goal-directed therapy (GDT) is a term used to describe the use of cardiac output or similar parameters to guide intravenous (IV) fluid and inotropic therapy. In the present study, GDT was used to optimize the various hemodynamic variables in the post-CPB period in high-risk patients with European system for cardiac operative risk evaluation (EuROSCORE) ≥3 undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) in the study group, whereas the control group comprised patients managed without using GDT. In the patients receiving GDT, the additional aims were to maintain the cardiac index (CI) between 2.5 and 4.2 L/min/m 2, stroke volume index (SVI) 30–65 ml/beat/m 2, systemic vascular resistance index (SVRI) 1500–2500 dynes/s/cm 5/m 2, oxygen delivery index (DO2I) 450–600 ml/min/m 2, continuous central venous oxygen saturation (ScVO2) >70%, and stroke volume variation (SVV) <10%. All data gathered in this study were derived using the FloTrac™ (a new minimally invasive cardiac output monitor) cardiac output sensor, and the PreSep™ catheter in conjunction with the Vigileo monitor (Edwards Life Sciences, Irvine, CA, USA).
Besides hemodynamic parameters, a plethora of biomarkers pertaining to myocardial, renal function, and the overall tissue perfusion have been described in recent years. The biomarkers such as brain natriuretic peptide (BNP) and neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin (NGAL) correlate well with the clinical outcomes in various studies involving the use of GDT., This study also aimed at comparing the biomarkers between the patients undergoing CABG with or without GDT for establishing the utility of GDT in the perioperative care of high-risk cardiac surgical patients.
| Materials and Methods|| |
The study was conducted in two cardiac surgical centers after obtaining ethical clearance from the Institutional Review Board and informed consent. One hundred and thirty patients of either sex with a EuroSCORE ≥3 undergoing CABG were included in this prospective randomized controlled study. The patients were divided randomly into two groups, namely, control and GDT groups, by the sealed envelope technique. Patients with cardiac dysrhythmias and contraindication to the central venous cannulation were excluded from the study. Patients requiring the initiation of intra-aortic balloon pump (IABP) therapy were excluded from the study because the FloTrac™ is not equipped to identify the waveforms of arterial pressure waveform while using IABP.
Induction and maintenance of general anesthesia was done in accordance with the institutional protocol. Electrocardiogram (ECG), oxygen saturation (SpO2), invasive blood pressure, central venous pressure (CVP) and arterial blood gas (ABG), urine output, and EtCO2 monitoring were common to both the groups. In addition, the CI using FloTrac/volumeView set (Edwards Life Sciences Ltd.) and the ScVO2 using PreSep catheter were monitored in the GDT group. A VolumeView™ cardiac output monitoring sensor was connected to the radial arterial cannula in the GDT group. PreSep™ catheter (continuous central venous oximetry) was inserted in the GDT group. The baseline readings (T1) of heart rate (HR), mean arterial pressure (MAP), CVP, SpO2, and ABG were recorded.The additional baseline readings (T1) of CI, SVRI, DO2I, SVI, SVV, and ScVO2 were recorded in the patients in the GDT group. The blood samples were collected for T1 values of BNP, NGAL, and lactate in all the patients.
The CPB was initiated after systemic heparinization and was maintained as per standard institutional protocols. The rewarming was accompanied by administering IV infusion of dobutamine at 5 µg/kg/min and 0.5 µg/kg/min nitroglycerin or any other vasoactive/vasodilator drug depending on patients' condition. After separation from CPB, protamine sulfate was administered in a dose of 1.2 mg/mg of heparin to antagonize the effects of heparin. Thereafter, the patients received 0.1 U/kg of platelet transfusion. All patients received fluids to maintain the CVP between 6 and 8 mmHg  and MAP was maintained between 90 and 105 mmHg using inotropic agents (dobutamine, dopamine, adrenaline, noradrenaline, and milrinone) and vasodilators. ABG and urinary output was monitored on an hourly basis, and the biochemical abnormalities corrected as necessary. Hematocrit (HCT) values were maintained at or above 30% with packed cell transfusions.
The goal-directed therapy algorithm
In accordance with the GDT, if the CI was <2.5 L/min/m 2, CVP <6 mmHg, or SVV >10%, fluids (100 ml aliquots of fluid) were given intravenously till the target CVP and SVV levels were achieved [Figure 1]. Inotropic agents and vasodilators were adjusted to maintain the parameters within the target values. The choice of inotropes was determined by MAP, SV, and SVRI. If ScVO2 was <70%, packed red cells were administered to maintain HCT >30% and if ScVO2 continued to be <70%, GDT was initiated to achieve the CI at 2.5–4.2 L/min/m 2, SVI at 30–65 ml/beat/m 2, SVRI at 1600–2600 dyne/s/cm 5/m 2, DO2I at 450–600 ml/min/m 2, ScVO2 >70%, and SVV <10%; in addition to the goals in the standard care such as CVP 6–8 mmHg, MAP at 90–105 mmHg, ABG analysis values (pH 7.35–45, PaO2 >100 mmHg, and PaCO2 35–45 mmHg), SpO2 >95%, HCT >30%, and urine output >1 ml/kg/h. The monitoring was gradually withdrawn after 24 h.
|Figure 1: The step-wise algorithm followed in the study to allocate, study, and manage the patients receiving goal-directed and conventional therapy|
Click here to view
The parameters recorded at the closure of sternum were designated as T2 and blood lactate (T2) was estimated. All patients were mechanically ventilated in the ICU and monitored with FlowTrac for 24 h. HR, MAP, SpO2, CVP, and peripheral temperature were monitored continuously and recorded at 0 (T3), 6 (T4), 12 (T5), and 24 (T6) h after transfer to the ICU. Blood samples were collected postoperatively at 6 and 24 h for T4 and T6 values of BNP and NGAL and 0, 6, 12, and 24 h for T3, T4, T5, and T6 values of lactate.
Early postoperative care in the ICU was jointly determined by the cardiac surgical and ICU staff, as per standard practice. Patients were weaned off when they were fully awake and adequately rewarmed (core temperature ≥36°) with normal skeletal muscle power, hemodynamically stable with normal chest radiograph and ABG, chest-tube drainage <100 ml/h, and urine output >1 ml/kg/h. All extubated patients were transferred from the ICU on the 2nd day unless inotropes or vasodilator drugs were necessary. A 12-lead ECG was performed on the day 3. The criteria for discharge from hospital comprised a stable cardiac rhythm, oral temperature <99°F, HCT ≥25%, oral intake of a minimum of 1000 calories/day, and successful completion of exercise testing that included independent ambulation, no significant wound-related complications, and an adequate home support system. Patients were contacted by phone at 30 days and their medical records reviewed to ascertain if they experienced any adverse outcomes.
Discrete categorical data were presented as number or percentage. The normality of quantitative data was checked by measures of Kolmogorov–Smirnov tests of normality. Continuous data were written either in the form of its mean and standard deviation or in the form of its median and interquartile range, as per the requirement. For normally distributed data, t-test was applied for statistical analysis of two groups. For skewed data, nonparametric Mann–Whitney U-test was used for statistical analysis of two groups. For time-related variable, Wilcoxon signed-rank test was applied. For categorical data, comparisons were made by Pearson's Chi-square test or Fisher's exact test as appropriate. All the statistical tests were two-sided and were performed at a significance level of α = 0.05. Analysis was conducted using IBM SPSS Statistics (version 22.0, IBM corporation, USA).
| Results|| |
To begin with, there were a total of 130 patients. Five patients from both the groups were excluded from the study since three patients in the control and one in the GDT group required IABP and postoperative atrial or ventricular fibrillation resulted in two and four patients in the control and the study group, respectively. The results of the remaining sixty patients in each group were analyzed. Demographic data and EuroSCORE, duration of CPB, duration of aortic cross-clamping (AOXCL), and an average number of grafts/patient were comparable [Table 1]. HR, MAP, CVP, SpO2, and ABG at various time intervals were comparable between the groups [Table 2]. The patients in the GDT group produced more urine during the study period, which was not statistically significant from the result of the control. ScVO2, CI, SVV, SVRI, SVI, and DO2I were maintained within the physiological values in the GDT group.
|Table 2: Heart rate, mean arterial pressure, and central venous pressure in the two groups|
Click here to view
There was statistically significant difference in the extra volume used (343.33 ± 62.02 and 376.33 ± 55.23, P = 0.003) and the number of times the inotropic agent was changed (2.77 ± 0.91 and 3.12 ± 0.80, P = 0.029) in the control and GDT groups, respectively [Table 3]. The average duration of ventilation (19.89 ± 3.96 vs. 18.05 ± 4.53 h, P = 0.025), hospital stay (7.94 ± 1.64 vs. 7.17 ± 1.93d, P = 0.025), and ICU stay (3.74 ± 0.59 vs. 3.41 ± 0.75 d, P = 0.012) was significantly less in the GDT group, compared to those in the control group [Table 3]. The duration of inotropic support was less in the GDT group though not significant as compared to the control. One patient in GDT group and three patients in the control group had renal dysfunction, which improved by administering diuretics. Total four patients (one in GDT and three in control) required IABP support. There were two mortalities in the study group and six mortalities in the control group during the study period. The causes ranged from malignant arrhythmias to refractory hemodynamic instability.
|Table 3: Comparison of the outcomes between the control and the goal--directed therapy group|
Click here to view
With regard to the biomarkers, the continuation of GDT in the ICU helped reduction in the lactate levels at T4 onward, whereas the control group recorded maximum lactate levels at T5 [Table 4]. At the same time, BNP and NGAL were significantly higher in the control group at T6 compared to the GDT group [Table 4].
| Discussion|| |
Organ dysfunction and multiple organ failure remain the main causes of prolonged hospital stay after cardiac surgery. Cardiac surgery patients are at risk of inadequate oxygen delivery in view of extracorporeal circulation and limited cardiovascular reserve.,
The aim of GDT is to maintain the CI, CVP, MAP, SVRI, DO2I, SVI, SVV, ScVO2, ABG, and urine output within the physiological limits by active intervention. Pölönen et al. studied 403 cardiac surgery patients and concluded that maintaining mixed venous oxygen saturation (SvO2) >70%, decreases the length of stay (LOS)-ICU and LOS-hospital. Patients in the high-risk group who tend to have increased morbidity and mortality may benefit from intensive monitoring and early interventions. Therefore, in this study, we wished to study the utility of GDT in patients who with EuroSCORE ≥3 points (medium and high-risk).
Mixed venous oxygen saturation is ideally measured by estimating the oxygen content of the blood drawn from the pulmonary artery through pulmonary artery catheter (PAC). Goldman et al. studied the importance of ScVO2 in 31 patients with myocardial infarction. PreSep™ central venous oximetry catheter can be used to continuously monitor the ScVO2 (though not similar to SvO2, correlates well with SvO2). The mixed venous oxygen saturation estimated from the superior vena cava was found to be 5%–13% lower than that estimated from the PAC.
In cardiac surgery, GDT was commenced using a noninvasive method such as esophageal Doppler instead of the PAC to measure the cardiac output.,, Unlike the FloTrac™, Doppler probe is not readily tolerated by conscious patients, restricting its use to patients who are ventilated, and the PAC is invasive with its own set of complications. Studies by Manecke et al., McGee et al., and Chakravarthy et al., have validated the Vigileo system.,, However, Opdam et al. showed a limited correlation for CI between FloTrac™ and PAC.
A study by Smetkin et al. showed that a goal-directed algorithm based on continuous measurement of ScVO2 could improve the course of the postoperative period after CABG on the beating heart. In a 15-year follow-up, Rhodes et al. evaluated GDT in high-risk surgical patients, demonstrating improved long-term outcomes.
The authors had previously conducted a clinical outcome comparison study between the GDT and the control groups in a small number of patients with inconclusive results. Keeping in view the advent and validation of biomarkers for predicting organ dysfunction after cardiac surgery,, the authors planned a comparison between the GDT and conventional hemodynamic management with clinical and biochemical outcomes in a larger number of patients.
The average duration of ventilation, hospital stay, ICU stay was significantly less in the GDT group, compared to those in the control group [Table 3]. The duration of inotropic support was less in the GDT group though not significant as compared to the control. There was statistically significant difference in the extra volume used and the number of times the inotropic agent was changed in the control and GDT groups, both being higher in the GDT group to meet the desired hemodynamic goals.
As depicted in [Figure 2], the continuation of GDT in the perioperative period in the ICU helped in stabilization of the lactate levels at T4 onward, whereas the control group recorded maximum lactate levels at T5. It was noteworthy that NGAL levels (as well as BNP) were significantly higher in the control group after 24 h as compared to the GDT group though the urine output difference between the groups was still insignificant [Figure 3]. This highlights the importance of biomarkers in early detection of organ dysfunction after cardiac surgery. Close hemodynamic, clinical, and biomarker-based monitoring continued from the perioperative to the intensive care setting provides early mobilization in a safe manner postcardiac surgery.,,
|Figure 2: The lactate at T1 (baseline), T2 (sternal closure), T3 (0), T4 (6), T5 (12), and T6 (24) h in Intensive Care Unit. The arrow shows the peak in the groups|
Click here to view
|Figure 3: The brain natriuretic peptide, neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin, average hourly urine output at T1, T4, T6, where the rise in brain natriuretic peptide/neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin is clear at T6|
Click here to view
This study had a few limitations: In spite of involving a considerable number of patients in a randomized fashion, the study could not be blinded. Second, the present study being a multicenter study, the patients enrolled in the study were operated upon by center-specific surgical teams. Preload markers of global end-diastolic volume index and extravascular lung water could not be completed in all sixty patients; hence their values were not included in the study. These markers which give more information on volume status should be part of a futuristic trial, as it substantiates adequately the efficacy of GDT.
| Conclusion|| |
Perioperative GDT can shorten the duration of ventilator dependency, ICU and hospital stay in high-risk cardiac surgical patients. The significantly lower levels of biomarkers in GDT group further support the importance of optimizing the hemodynamic parameters for the maintenance of tissue perfusion. This attests to the cost-effectiveness of GDT in the management of a subset of patients at higher risk of morbidity and mortality after cardiac surgery.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Higgins TL, Yared JP, Ryan T. Immediate postoperative care of cardiac surgical patients. J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 1996;10:643-58.
Ryan TA, Rady MY, Bashour CA, Leventhal M, Lytle B, Starr NJ. Predictors of outcome in cardiac surgical patients with prolonged intensive care stay. Chest 1997;112:1035-42.
Routsi C, Vincent JL, Bakker J, De Backer D, Lejeune P, d'Hollander A, et al.
Relation between oxygen consumption and oxygen delivery in patients after cardiac surgery. Anesth Analg 1993;77:1104-10.
Warner CD, Weintraub WS, Craver JM, Jones EL, Gott JP, Guyton RA. Effect of cardiac surgery patient characteristics on patient outcomes from 1981 through 1995. Circulation 1997;96:1575-9.
Shoemaker WC, Appel PL, Waxman K, Schwartz S, Chang P. Clinical trial of survivors' cardiorespiratory patterns as therapeutic goals in critically ill postoperative patients. Crit Care Med 1982;10:398-403.
Bland R, Shoemaker WC, Shabot MM. Physiologic monitoring goals for the critically ill patient. Surg Gynecol Obstet 1978;147:833-41.
Beal AL, Cerra FB. Multiple organ failure syndrome in the 1990s. Systemic inflammatory response and organ dysfunction. JAMA 1994;271:226-33.
Pearse R, Dawson D, Fawcett J, Rhodes A, Grounds RM, Bennett ED. Early goal-directed therapy after major surgery reduces complications and duration of hospital stay. A randomised, controlled trial [ISRCTN38797445]. Crit Care 2005;9:R687-93.
Nashef SA, Roques F, Michel P, Gauducheau E, Lemeshow S, Salamon R. European system for cardiac operative risk evaluation (EuroSCORE). Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 1999;16:9-13.
Mishra J, Dent C, Tarabishi R, Mitsnefes MM, Ma Q, Kelly C, et al.
Neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin (NGAL) as a biomarker for acute renal injury after cardiac surgery. Lancet 2005;365:1231-8.
Frangogiannis NG. Biomarkers: Hopes and challenges in the path from discovery to clinical practice. Transl Res 2012;159:197-204.
Mythen MG, Webb AR. Perioperative plasma volume expansion reduces the incidence of gut mucosal hypoperfusion during cardiac surgery. Arch Surg 1995;130:423-9.
Pölönen P, Ruokonen E, Hippeläinen M, Pöyhönen M, Takala J. A prospective, randomized study of goal-oriented hemodynamic therapy in cardiac surgical patients. Anesth Analg 2000;90:1052-9.
Goldman RH, Klughaupt M, Metcalf T, Spivack AP, Harrison DC. Measurement of central venous oxygen saturation in patients with myocarial infarction. Circulation 1968;38:941-6.
Lee J, Wright F, Barber R, Stanley L. Central venous oxygen saturation in shock: A study in man. Anesthesiology 1972;36:472-8.
McKendry M, McGloin H, Saberi D, Caudwell L, Brady AR, Singer M. Randomised controlled trial assessing the impact of a nurse delivered, flow monitored protocol for optimisation of circulatory status after cardiac surgery. BMJ 2004;329:258.
Wakeling HG, McFall MR, Jenkins CS, Woods WG, Miles WF, Barclay GR, et al.
Intraoperative oesophageal Doppler guided fluid management shortens postoperative hospital stay after major bowel surgery. Br J Anaesth 2005;95:634-42.
Gan TJ, Soppitt A, Maroof M, el-Moalem H, Robertson KM, Moretti E, et al.
Goal-directed intraoperative fluid administration reduces length of hospital stay after major surgery. Anesthesiology 2002;97:820-6.
Manecke GR Jr., Auger WR. Cardiac output determination from the arterial pressure wave: Clinical testing of a novel algorithm that does not require calibration. J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 2007;21:3-7.
McGee WT, Horswell JL, Calderon J, Janvier G, Van Severen T, Van den Berghe G, et al.
Validation of a continuous, arterial pressure-based cardiac output measurement: A multicenter, prospective clinical trial. Crit Care 2007;11:R105.
Chakravarthy M, Patil TA, Jayaprakash K, Kalligudd P, Prabhakumar D, Jawali V. Comparison of simultaneous estimation of cardiac output by four techniques in patients undergoing off-pump coronary artery bypass surgery – A prospective observational study. Ann Card Anaesth 2007;10:121-6.
Opdam HI, Wan L, Bellomo R. A pilot assessment of the FloTrac cardiac output monitoring system. Intensive Care Med 2007;33:344-9.
Smetkin AA, Kirov MY, Kuzkov VV, Lenkin AI, Eremeev AV, Slastilin VY, et al.
Single transpulmonary thermodilution and continuous monitoring of central venous oxygen saturation during off-pump coronary surgery. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2009;53:505-14.
Rhodes A, Cecconi M, Hamilton M, Poloniecki J, Woods J, Boyd O, et al.
Goal-directed therapy in high-risk surgical patients: A 15-year follow-up study. Intensive Care Med 2010;36:1327-32.
Kapoor PM, Kakani M, Chowdhury U, Choudhury M, Lakshmy KU. Early goal-directed therapy in moderate to high-risk cardiac surgery patients. Ann Card Anaesth 2008;11:27-34.
Cassina T, Putzu A, Santambrogio L, Villa M, Licker MJ. Hemodynamic challenge to early mobilization after cardiac surgery: A pilot study. Ann Card Anaesth 2016;19:425-32.
Chowdhury UK, Sheil A, Kapoor PM, Narang R, Gharde P, Malik V, et al.
Short-term prognostic value of perioperative coronary sinus-derived-serum cardiac troponin-I, creatine kinase-MB, lactate, pyruvate, and lactate-pyruvate ratio in adult patients undergoing open heart surgery. Ann Card Anaesth 2016;19:439-53.
Bignami E, Frati E, Meroni R, Simonini M, Di Prima AL, Manunta P, et al.
Urinary neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin time course during cardiac surgery. Ann Card Anaesth 2015;18:39-44.
Poonam Malhotra Kapoor
Department of Cardiac Anaesthesia, CTC, AIIMS, New Delhi
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
[Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3]
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4]